Sunfiber vs. Other Fiber Supplements (Psyllium, Inulin, Acacia & More)

Choosing the right fiber supplement can be surprisingly confusing. Walk down the supplement aisle and you will find psyllium husk, inulin, acacia fiber, methylcellulose, wheat dextrin, and a growing number of specialty options. Each one claims to support digestive health, yet they differ significantly in how they work, how they taste, and how your body tolerates them.

If you have IBS, FODMAP sensitivities, or simply want a fiber that won't cause bloating, these differences matter. In this guide we compare four of the most popular fiber supplements — Sunfiber (PHGG), psyllium husk, inulin, and acacia fiber — so you can make an informed choice backed by evidence, not marketing.

For a deeper look at the science behind PHGG, see our Complete Guide to Partially Hydrolyzed Guar Gum.

Sunfiber (PHGG)

Partially hydrolyzed guar gum (PHGG) — sold under the brand name Sunfiber — is a soluble prebiotic fiber derived from guar beans. The guar gum is enzymatically broken down into a low-viscosity powder that dissolves clear in any liquid without changing taste, texture, or smell.

Key Strengths

• Low-FODMAP certified by Monash University — one of the very few fibers that carries this certification.
• Tasteless, odorless, dissolves clear — no gritty texture or unpleasant flavor.
• Minimal gas and bloating — PHGG ferments slowly and evenly in the colon, avoiding the rapid gas production common with other fibers.
• Regulating fiber — clinical studies show it helps both constipation and diarrhea, normalizing stool consistency rather than pushing it in one direction.
• High butyrate production — PHGG is one of the most efficient fibers for generating butyrate, a short-chain fatty acid that nourishes colon cells and reduces inflammation.
• 30+ years of clinical research supporting its safety and efficacy.

The main drawback is price: Sunfiber typically costs more per serving than generic psyllium or inulin. However, for anyone with a sensitive gut, the tolerability advantage can make it well worth the investment. Read our full Organic Sunfiber PHGG review for dosage, pricing, and detailed analysis.

Psyllium Husk

Psyllium husk is the most widely used fiber supplement in the world, best known through brands like Metamucil and Konsyl. It comes from the seed husks of the Plantago ovata plant and provides a mix of soluble and insoluble fiber.

Pros

• Affordable and widely available — sold in every pharmacy and grocery store.
• Strong clinical evidence for lowering cholesterol and improving regularity.
• Effective bulk-forming laxative — absorbs water and increases stool volume.
• FDA-approved health claims for heart health when part of a low-fat diet.

Cons

• Thickens liquids significantly — can become gel-like if not consumed quickly.
• Moderate gas and bloating, especially when starting or at higher doses.
• Not Low-FODMAP certified — some IBS patients tolerate it, but others do not.
• Must be taken with plenty of water to avoid intestinal blockage.
• Lower prebiotic activity compared to PHGG or inulin.

Psyllium remains an excellent budget option for general regularity and cholesterol support, but its texture and tolerability issues make it a less ideal choice for people with IBS or sensitive digestion.

Inulin

Inulin is a soluble prebiotic fiber found naturally in chicory root, garlic, onions, and Jerusalem artichokes. It is widely used in processed foods as a fiber additive and is available as a standalone supplement.

Pros

• Strong prebiotic effect — feeds Bifidobacteria and other beneficial gut microbes.
• Mildly sweet taste — can partially replace sugar in recipes.
• Affordable and available in bulk powder form.

Cons

• High-FODMAP — inulin is a fructan, one of the most common IBS triggers. Monash University classifies it as high-FODMAP at typical supplement doses.
• Significant gas and bloating — inulin ferments rapidly in the colon, often causing uncomfortable gas, cramping, and distension, even in people without IBS.
• Not suitable for anyone following a Low-FODMAP diet.
• Can worsen symptoms for people with SIBO (small intestinal bacterial overgrowth).

Inulin is a potent prebiotic, but its high-FODMAP status and tendency to cause digestive discomfort make it a poor choice for anyone with IBS or a sensitive gut. If you tolerate it well, it can be a cost-effective way to support your microbiome — but proceed with caution.

Acacia Fiber

Acacia fiber (also called gum arabic) is a soluble prebiotic fiber harvested from the sap of the Acacia senegal tree. It has been used for centuries and has gained popularity as a gentle, natural fiber supplement.

Pros

• Generally well tolerated — ferments slowly, producing less gas than inulin.
• Prebiotic properties — supports the growth of Bifidobacteria and Lactobacilli.
• Natural and minimally processed — often organic and sustainably sourced.
• Generally considered Low-FODMAP friendly at moderate doses.

Cons

• Limited clinical evidence compared to PHGG and psyllium — fewer large-scale human trials.
• Slightly gummy texture when mixed into liquids.
• Not formally certified Low-FODMAP by Monash University.
• May cause mild bloating at higher doses.

Acacia fiber is a reasonable middle-ground option. It is gentler than inulin and more palatable than psyllium for many users, but it lacks the depth of clinical research and formal Low-FODMAP certification that Sunfiber PHGG offers.

Head-to-Head Comparison Table

Here is how all four fiber supplements compare across the criteria that matter most:

Which Fiber Supplement Is Right for You?

The best fiber supplement depends on your individual health goals, digestive sensitivities, and budget. Here are our recommendations based on common scenarios:

If You Have IBS or FODMAP Sensitivities

Choose Sunfiber (PHGG). It is the only major fiber supplement with formal Low-FODMAP certification from Monash University. Its slow, gentle fermentation profile means minimal gas and bloating — exactly what IBS sufferers need. Avoid inulin entirely, and use psyllium with caution. Learn more in our article on how Sunfiber can help IBS on a Low-FODMAP diet.

If You Are on a Budget

Consider psyllium husk. It is the most affordable fiber supplement available and has a long track record for improving regularity and supporting heart health. Just be prepared for the thick texture and the possibility of some gas when starting out.

If You Want General Gut Health Support

Sunfiber or acacia fiber are both strong options. Sunfiber edges ahead on clinical evidence and butyrate production, while acacia fiber can be a good choice if you prefer a more natural, minimally processed supplement. Both are well tolerated by most people.

If You Want Maximum Prebiotic Effect (and Tolerate FODMAPs)

Inulin delivers a potent prebiotic punch, but only if your gut can handle it. If you have no history of IBS, SIBO, or excessive bloating, inulin can be an effective and affordable way to boost beneficial gut bacteria. Start with a low dose and increase gradually.

Our Recommendation

After evaluating the clinical evidence, tolerability, and real-world usability of each fiber supplement, Sunfiber PHGG is our top pick for most people. Here is why:

• It is the only fiber with Monash Low-FODMAP certification, making it safe for the broadest range of users.
• Its tasteless, odorless, clear-dissolving formula removes the compliance barrier that causes many people to quit other fiber supplements.
• It produces more butyrate than psyllium, inulin, or acacia — directly nourishing your colon lining.
• It regulates both constipation and diarrhea, unlike psyllium which primarily addresses constipation.
• It is backed by over three decades of peer-reviewed clinical research.

The slightly higher price per serving is, in our view, justified by the superior tolerability and clinical backing. For a full breakdown of dosing, pricing, and sourcing, read our in-depth Organic Sunfiber PHGG review.

To understand the science behind how prebiotic fiber benefits your health, check out our companion article covering the five key benefits backed by research.

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.